After consulting w/ the moderation first, I've decided to bump this thread in order to make a 2010 vs 2025 comparison.
@josh_the_hot_boy I don't think you did anything wrong, and you certainly did not have to apologize. You made it very clear that you posted this for the purpose of discussion, not to point fingers. If it's okay for some to argue in support of piracy, it's okay for others to argue against it or have a neutral viewpoint on the matter. Nobody has to take it personally.
The more I think of it, the more unfair I think piracy is. For instance... I'm a subscriber of several paysites, incl. MEN and Broke Straight Boys. Each new release systematically appear on certain pirate sites just one day after publication.
How is it fair to me, a (permanent) paying subscriber?
One particular pirate site currently hosts 935 MEN scenes and 264 BSB scenes. Sure, it's not the whole catalogues of those studios, but still... All the new updates show, which makes the "exclusivity" those paysites offer an illusion. In official terms, I'm paying for exclusivity, but it is evidently an illusion, esp. since those same scenes oftentimes have more views on the pirate sites than the official sites.
Rene Nijstad explained in details all the costs involved in running a studio... OF/JFF models often assume the same costs: transportation, accommodation, health testing, technical assistance (filming, lighting, editing, etc.), logistics (incl. rental of locations), and medication (Viagra, Cialis, or Tri-Mix). Add to that additional medication (like PrEP and DoxyPEP), gym memberships, dietary supplements, clothing (incl. luxury underwear or S&M gear), etc. In some cases, models will pay for therapy and antidepressants.
Some criticize certain studios for not paying their models more
while consuming the leaks instead of paying for membership... And what about those who pirate OF/JFF models? What's the excuse, then?
I now avoid pirated stuff—as in commercially available full-length scenes (whether on here or anywhere else). I prefer sticking to my own subs and authorized free stuff.
It appears that OTB closed not so long after this thread was made... I'm sorry it had to come to that. Some commented that maybe OTB did not renew itself enough or the scenes were not up to par... If so, why was it massively pirated? If it sucked so much, it would not have been so pirated.
In 2025, it's a miracle that many studios still exist... And they solely exist because of the remaining paying subscribers that some pirates see as "simps." If it weren't for the "simps" paying, there'd be no more productions, and therefore nothing left to pirate. Same thing when it comes to personal portals such as OF, JFF, Raw Fuck Club, and Fansly.
Paying subscribers may no longer pay for exclusivity, but they at least keep production going and models fed and cared for. Something to think about!